Why the Swiss Love Their Guns (more than Americans)

Why the Swiss Love Their Guns (more than Americans)
Quizzed ESL Activities

Gun Culture: A Comparative Analysis of Switzerland and the United States

In Switzerland, a peaceful and neutral country, a unique gun culture exists where citizens are given guns and trained to shoot, with almost as many guns per person as in the United States, yet with a much lower crime rate. This phenomenon has sparked interest in understanding the vastly different relationships with guns between the two countries.

Historical Background

The story of Switzerland begins with a group of people making a promise to each other 700 years ago, and the legend of William Tell, who defied a king’s local leader and famously shot an apple off his son’s head with a crossbow. This heroic act inspired tribes to launch a rebellion, which ultimately led to the formation of the Swiss Confederacy. The Swiss made an agreement to protect each other, arming and training ordinary people to fight as a militia rather than a standing army.

The Swiss Militia System

Switzerland’s militia system, which required all citizens to have a gun and ammo, was of particular interest to American founding fathers, including John Adams. The concept of a militia was later enshrined in the Constitution to protect the government and country from invasion or insurrection. In Switzerland, citizens are required to keep firearms at home and practice shooting annually at private clubs, a mandate known as the “obligator”. They can freely transport their guns, even on public transport, and are expected to be ready to defend their country if necessary.

Contrasting Gun Cultures

In contrast to the United States, where the right to bear arms is constitutionally enshrined, guns in Switzerland are viewed as a duty to protect the country, with a strong tradition of responsibility and a militia system where every man must learn to shoot for collective national defense. Guns are a symbol of community and celebration, often at the center of large festivals and shooting competitions, such as those held in Zurich or by the Alps.

The Evolution of Gun Culture in the United States

After gaining independence, the United States learned that a militia was insufficient for conquest and expansion, leading to the establishment of a professional standing army. The right to bear arms became a personal tool for Americans to pursue their dreams, hunt, and protect their families. In the 1960s and 1970s, guns took on a more personal symbol as trust in the government declined and crime rates skyrocketed, leading to a surge in gun ownership and the growth of the NRA as a symbol of personal defense and anti-government sentiment.

The NRA and Gun Lobbying

The NRA was taken over by hardliners in the 1970s who changed its agenda to a political lobbying group focused on reshaping Americans’ views on the Second Amendment, pushing for individual protection and the right to bear arms, and deemphasizing the connection to a well-regulated militia. This ultimately led to the Second Amendment becoming a guarantee for individuals to have guns for self-protection, resulting in thousands of annual gun-related murders, accidents, and suicides.

Comparing Gun Policies

Efforts to pass reasonable gun laws in the United States continually fail due to the NRA’s politicization of guns. In contrast, countries like Switzerland have a more nuanced approach to gun ownership, with a focus on collective defense and responsibility. Gun rights are deeply tied to personal protection and liberty in America, making significant changes to gun legislation unlikely.

Conclusion

The comparison between Switzerland and the United States highlights the complex and multifaceted nature of gun culture, influenced by societal stories and myths. Understanding these differences is crucial for developing effective gun policies that balance individual rights with collective security and responsibility.

Key Takeaways

  • Switzerland has a unique gun culture with a strong emphasis on collective defense and responsibility.
  • The United States has a more individualistic approach to gun ownership, with a focus on personal protection and liberty.
  • The NRA has played a significant role in shaping American gun culture and lobbying for individual gun rights.
  • Comparing gun policies between countries can provide valuable insights into developing effective solutions for gun-related issues.

Key Vocabulary

Term Definition Example Usage
Militia A group of citizens who are trained to fight in times of war or emergency, often in place of a standing army. In Switzerland, the militia system requires all citizens to have a gun and ammo, and to practice shooting annually.
Gun Culture The attitudes, values, and practices surrounding the use and ownership of guns in a society. The United States and Switzerland have distinct gun cultures, with the US focusing on individual rights and Switzerland emphasizing collective defense.
Second Amendment A constitutional amendment in the United States that guarantees the right to bear arms. The NRA has played a significant role in shaping the interpretation of the Second Amendment, emphasizing individual protection and the right to bear arms.
NRA (National Rifle Association) A powerful lobbying group in the United States that advocates for gun rights and influences gun policies. The NRA has been instrumental in blocking efforts to pass stricter gun laws in the United States, citing the need to protect individual rights and liberties.
Collective Defense A concept where citizens work together to defend their country or community, often through a militia system. Switzerland’s gun culture is centered around collective defense, with citizens viewing gun ownership as a duty to protect their country and community.
Personal Protection The use of guns for self-defense and protection of one’s family and property. In the United States, the right to bear arms is often justified as a means of personal protection, with many citizens owning guns for this purpose.
Gun-Related Violence Violence or harm caused by the use of guns, including murders, accidents, and suicides. The United States experiences a high rate of gun-related violence, with thousands of deaths and injuries occurring each year.
Gun Laws Regulations and policies governing the ownership, use, and sale of guns in a society. Countries like Switzerland have stricter gun laws than the United States, with a focus on collective defense and responsibility rather than individual rights.
Gun Ownership The possession and use of guns by individuals or groups in a society. Gun ownership rates vary significantly between the United States and Switzerland, with the US having a much higher rate of gun ownership despite similar rates of gun-related violence.

Watch The Video

Why the Swiss Love Their Guns (more than Americans)

Vocabulary Quiz

1. Which word means ‘a group of people who are trained to fight but are not professional soldiers’?

A) Militia
B) Army
C) Insurrection
D) Rebellion

2. What is the term for the mandate in Switzerland where citizens are required to practice shooting annually at private clubs?

A) Obligator
B) Militia System
C) Collective Defense
D) Personal Protection

3. In the context of the United States, what event led to a surge in gun ownership and the growth of the NRA?

A) The establishment of a professional standing army
B) The decline of trust in the government and skyrocketing crime rates in the 1960s and 1970s
C) The formation of the Swiss Confederacy
D) The legend of William Tell

4. Which organization has played a significant role in shaping American gun culture and lobbying for individual gun rights?

A) The Swiss Confederacy
B) The United States Army
C) The National Rifle Association (NRA)
D) The Swiss Militia

5. What is the main difference between the approach to gun ownership in Switzerland and the United States?

A) Switzerland has stricter gun laws than the United States
B) The United States has a more collective approach to gun ownership than Switzerland
C) Switzerland focuses on collective defense and responsibility, while the United States focuses on personal protection and liberty
D) The United States has a longer history of gun ownership than Switzerland

Answer Key:

1. A
2. A
3. B
4. C
5. C

Grammar Focus

Grammar Focus: The Use of the Subjunctive Mood in Contrasting Situations

The subjunctive mood is used to express doubt, uncertainty, or possibility about a situation. It can be particularly useful when contrasting two different scenarios or outcomes, as seen in the comparison between Switzerland and the United States. For example, “it is necessary that citizens be ready to defend their country” illustrates the use of the subjunctive mood to express a necessity or requirement. In the context of the provided text, the subjunctive mood can help to highlight the differences in gun culture and policies between the two countries, such as “it is crucial that gun policies balance individual rights with collective security.” The subjunctive mood is often introduced by verbs like “require,” “suggest,” “recommend,” or by expressions like “it is necessary,” “it is essential,” or “it is vital.”

Grammar Quiz:

Choose the correct form of the verb in parentheses to complete each sentence.

  1. It is necessary that all citizens _______ (be) aware of their responsibilities in gun ownership.
    1. A) are
    2. B) be
    3. C) been
    4. D) being
  2. I suggest that the government _______ (take) a more nuanced approach to gun legislation.
    1. A) takes
    2. B) taking
    3. C) take
    4. D) took
  3. It is crucial that gun policies _______ (balance) individual rights with collective security.
    1. A) balances
    2. B) balance
    3. C) balancing
    4. D) balanced
  4. The NRA recommends that all gun owners _______ (undergo) regular training and background checks.
    1. A) undergo
    2. B) undergoes
    3. C) undergoing
    4. D) went through
  5. It is essential that the comparison between Switzerland and the United States _______ (provide) valuable insights into gun culture.
    1. A) provides
    2. B) providing
    3. C) provide
    4. D) provided

Answer Key:

  1. B) be
  2. C) take
  3. B) balance
  4. A) undergo
  5. C) provide