The Polarizing Meat: Understanding the Pork Taboo
Pork is a polarizing meat, being the most popular in the world yet avoided by about a third of humanity due to religious or cultural beliefs. Islam and Hinduism have strict prohibitions or reservations against consuming it, and despite extensive scholarly debate, the historical origins of the pork taboo remain unclear.
Historical Background
Ancient Jewish law, as written in Leviticus and Deuteronomy, prohibits eating pork because pigs have a cloven hoof but do not chew their cud. Chewing cud refers to the process of digesting and regurgitating food, specifically cellulose in plants, which is unique to ruminants like cows, goats, and sheep, allowing them to break down and extract nutrients from plant material.
The Quran forbids eating pork, along with carrion and blood, which are prone to harboring pathogens and toxins. Some people believe the prohibition against pork is an ancient health and safety code, a theory that gained traction in the 19th century with the discovery of the link between trichinosis and roundworms found in pigs.
Theories Behind the Pork Taboo
There are several theories behind the pork taboo, including:
- Health and Safety Code: The prohibition against pork may have originated as a way to protect people from diseases like trichinosis, which is caused by roundworms in undercooked pork.
- Cultural and Religious Beliefs: The pork taboo may have originated as a way to distinguish oneself from other people, eventually becoming a mechanism for assimilation and cultural identity.
- Environmental Factors: The arid environment of the Middle East, combined with the region’s deforestation and desertification, may have made pigs uneconomical and led to religious prohibitions on consuming pork.
Debunking the Health and Safety Code Theory
Recent scholarship, including work by anthropologist Marvin Harris, casts doubt on the theory that the pork taboo originated as a health and safety code. Harris argues that:
- Pork is not exceptionally hazardous, and all domestic animals can pose health risks to humans.
- Ancient people were aware of anthrax, but there is no evidence that they knew about trichinosis, which causes relatively mild illnesses that can take years to develop.
- The idea of trichinosis being a problem in ancient times is a case of modern people projecting their own experiences onto ancient lives, as trichinosis was primarily a problem in 19th century Europe and America.
Alternative Explanations
Maimonides, a philosopher and rabbi, wrote about the pork taboo 800 years ago, stating that the reason for the prohibition is due to pigs’ dirty and loathsome habits and food sources, making them unappetizing. However, this explanation is not universally accepted, and there may be more to the taboo than just the animal’s behavior.
Pigs only resort to filthy behavior when they have no other option, and their natural behavior is to root around in forests for food. However, due to deforestation and desertification in the ancient Middle East, pigs were forced to wallow in mud to stay cool, and later, with urbanization, they had to wallow in their own excrement, leading to their reputation as filthy animals.
Conclusion
The origin of the pork taboo remains unclear, but it is likely that it originated as a combination of cultural, religious, and environmental factors. Regardless of the reason, the pork taboo has had a significant impact on the way people eat and interact with each other.
If you’re looking to create a website to share your thoughts and recipes, regardless of your dietary code or religious beliefs, consider using Squarespace, a website builder that offers easy-to-use templates and built-in features. Save 10% on Squarespace by using the link in the description.
Key Vocabulary
| Term | Definition | Example Usage |
|---|---|---|
| Pork Taboo | A prohibition or avoidance of consuming pork due to religious or cultural beliefs. | The pork taboo is observed in Islam and Hinduism, where pork is considered haram or unclean. |
| Ruminants | Animals that have a four-chambered stomach and chew their cud, such as cows, goats, and sheep. | Cows are ruminants, which allows them to break down cellulose in plant material and extract nutrients. |
| Trichinosis | A disease caused by the roundworm Trichinella, often found in undercooked pork. | Trichinosis can be prevented by cooking pork thoroughly, as the parasite is killed by heat. |
| Cloven Hoof | A type of hoof found in some mammals, characterized by a split or divided hoof. | Pigs have a cloven hoof, but do not chew their cud, which is why they are considered unclean in some cultures. |
| Chewing Cud | The process of digesting and regurgitating food, specifically cellulose in plants, found in ruminant animals. | Cows chew their cud to break down cellulose in plant material and extract nutrients. |
| Deforestation | The removal of forests, usually as a result of human activities such as agriculture or urbanization. | Deforestation in the ancient Middle East may have contributed to the pork taboo, as pigs were forced to adapt to new environments. |
| Desertification | The process of land becoming desert-like, often due to climate change, overgrazing, or other human activities. | Desertification in the Middle East may have made pigs uneconomical to raise, contributing to the pork taboo. |
| Anthropologist | A scientist who studies human cultures, behaviors, and biology, past and present. | Marvin Harris, an anthropologist, argued that the pork taboo did not originate as a health and safety code. |
| Health and Safety Code | A set of rules or regulations intended to protect people from harm or disease. | Some people believe the pork taboo originated as a health and safety code, to protect people from diseases like trichinosis. |
| Cultural Identity | A person’s sense of belonging to a particular culture or group, often shaped by traditions, values, and beliefs. | The pork taboo may have originated as a way to distinguish oneself from other people, eventually becoming a mechanism for cultural identity. |
Watch The Video
Vocabulary Quiz
1. Which word means ‘to bring back up into the mouth to chew again’ in the context of how ruminants like cows digest their food?
A) Regurgitate
B) Digest
C) Chewing cud
D) Extract
2. What is the name of the disease caused by roundworms found in undercooked pork?
A) Anthrax
B) Trichinosis
C) Toxins
D) Pathogens
3. According to Marvin Harris, what is one argument against the theory that the pork taboo originated as a health and safety code?
A) Pork is exceptionally hazardous to human health.
B) Ancient people were aware of the risks of trichinosis.
C) All domestic animals can pose health risks to humans, and pork is not exceptionally hazardous.
D) The prohibition against pork is universally accepted across cultures.
4. What environmental factor in the Middle East may have contributed to the pork taboo by making pigs uneconomical?
A) Deforestation and desertification
B) Urbanization and industrialization
C) Overpopulation and poverty
D) Climate change and natural disasters
5. Who wrote about the pork taboo 800 years ago, stating that the reason for the prohibition is due to pigs’ dirty and loathsome habits and food sources?
A) Marvin Harris
B) Maimonides
C) A philosopher from ancient Greece
D) A rabbi from the Middle East
Answer Key:
1. C
2. B
3. C
4. A
5. B
Grammar Focus
Grammar Focus: The Use of the Subjunctive Mood
Grammar Quiz:
Choose the correct form of the verb in parentheses to complete each sentence.
1. It is necessary that the historical origins of the pork taboo (be, is, are, were) understood in order to appreciate its significance.
2. I suggest that the prohibition against pork (be, is, are, were) lifted in areas where it is not a health risk.
3. If the pork taboo (were, are, is, be) not in place, it is likely that more people would consume pork.
4. It is possible that the pork taboo (originate, originates, originated, were originated) as a combination of cultural, religious, and environmental factors.
5. The philosopher and rabbi, Maimonides, wrote that the reason for the prohibition (be, is, are, were) due to pigs’ dirty and loathsome habits and food sources.
Answer Key:
1. be
2. be
3. were
4. originated
5. was