US Airlines Industry Overview

The US airlines industry is characterized as an oligopoly, with United, American, and Delta Airlines offering similar services, including fees, leg room, snacks, and reliability. This convergence on product offerings allows them to avoid meaningful differentiation and price competition, instead focusing on competing through their network routes.

Competitive Strategies

The three largest US airlines do not compete on price due to alleged algorithm use to standardize fares. Instead, they focus on competing through their network routes, with each carving out a niche for themselves through subtle strategic differences in their route designs. United Airlines has found success with leisure-focused long-haul flights, such as to Tahiti or Cape Town, by being flexible and taking risks. American Airlines prioritizes its domestic “shoreline” network and only offers international connectivity as necessary to compete with United and Delta. Delta Airlines focuses on major tourist destinations and considers itself a premium airline, offering a differentiated experience.

Network Design and Route Strategies

United Airlines has a stronger presence in certain markets, including Osaka and Christchurch, where it is the only airline to offer non-stop flights from North America. The airline’s competitive advantage lies in its risk tolerance, allowing it to enter new markets before competitors like American or Delta. American Airlines, on the other hand, relies on London as a key European hub due to its geographical position and partnership with British Airways. Delta Airlines serves nine Mexican airports and has a limited presence in the Caribbean, where American Airlines dominates despite not being based in the region.

Hub Locations and Market Dominance

Denver is a better hub for United than Salt Lake City due to its larger local market, limitless room for airport expansion, and strategic geographic location for serving east-west passenger flows to mountain west destinations. Delta’s hubs have varying strengths, with Seattle being weaker than San Francisco and facing competition from Alaska Airlines, while Minneapolis and Detroit are overshadowed by Chicago. However, Atlanta stands out as the crown jewel of Delta’s network, perfectly located to capture massive north-south passenger flows and competitive for east-west traffic.

Brand Loyalty and Profitability

Delta is able to command a revenue premium due to its brand, product, and loyalty program, and has tended to beat United and American in profitability in recent years. The airline’s primary objective is a consistently high on-time rating, which is higher than United and American Airlines, and customers often report better service. American Airlines, on the other hand, focuses on minimizing costs and risk by concentrating their fleet on destinations with high onward connectivity, particularly in the sunbelt region where they are dominant.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the US airlines industry is characterized by a complex web of competitive strategies, network designs, and hub locations. United Airlines excels in leisure-focused long-haul flights, while American Airlines prioritizes its domestic network and Delta Airlines focuses on major tourist destinations. Understanding these strategies and market dynamics is crucial for airlines to stay competitive and profitable in the industry.

Key Vocabulary

Term	Definition	Example Usage
Oligopoly	A market structure in which a small number of firms compete with each other.	The US airlines industry is characterized as an oligopoly, with United, American, and Delta Airlines being the main competitors.
Convergence	The process of becoming similar or identical.	The three largest US airlines have converged on product offerings, including fees, leg room, snacks, and reliability.
Niche	A specialized market or segment.	Each airline has carved out a niche for themselves through subtle strategic differences in their route designs.
Algorithm	A set of instructions used to solve a problem or make a decision.	The three largest US airlines allegedly use algorithms to standardize fares and avoid price competition.
Network routes	The routes and connections between different destinations served by an airline.	The three largest US airlines compete through their network routes, with each airline offering unique connections and destinations.
Hub	A central airport or location that serves as a connection point for multiple flights and destinations.	Denver is a key hub for United Airlines, offering a strategic location for serving east-west passenger flows.
Brand loyalty	The tendency of customers to consistently choose a particular brand or product over others.	Delta Airlines is able to command a revenue premium due to its strong brand loyalty and customer satisfaction.
Profitability	The ability of a company to generate profits and remain financially sustainable.	Delta Airlines has tended to beat United and American Airlines in profitability in recent years due to its strong brand and customer loyalty.
On-time rating	A measure of an airline’s punctuality and ability to arrive at destinations on schedule.	Delta Airlines has a consistently high on-time rating, which is higher than United and American Airlines.
Revenue premium	The ability of a company to charge higher prices for its products or services due to its strong brand or market position.	Delta Airlines is able to command a revenue premium due to its strong brand and customer loyalty.
Competitive advantage	A unique benefit or characteristic that sets a company apart from its competitors and allows it to outperform them.	United Airlines’ risk tolerance and ability to enter new markets before its competitors is a key competitive advantage.
Geographical position	The location of a company or asset in relation to its market, customers, or competitors.	American Airlines’ partnership with British Airways is strengthened by London’s geographical position as a key European hub.
Partnership	A collaborative relationship between two or more companies or organizations.	American Airlines’ partnership with British Airways is an example of a strategic partnership in the airline industry.
Market dominance	The degree to which a company or product leads its market or industry.	Delta Airlines’ market dominance in Atlanta is an example of a company’s strong position in a particular market.
Customer satisfaction	The degree to which a customer is happy or content with a product or service.	Delta Airlines’ high customer satisfaction ratings are a key factor in its ability to command a revenue premium.

The Design of Airline Route Networks 🎓

Explore the advanced terminology extracted from the source material.

Watch The Video

The Design of Airline Route Networks

Vocabulary Quiz

1. What type of market structure is the US airlines industry characterized as?

A) Monopoly
B) Perfect Competition
C) Oligopoly
D) Monopsony

2. Why do the three largest US airlines not compete on price?

A) Due to high operational costs
B) Alleged algorithm use to standardize fares
C) Lack of demand for air travel
D) Government regulations

3. What is United Airlines’ competitive strategy in terms of route design?

A) Focusing on major tourist destinations
B) Prioritizing domestic shoreline network
C) Offering leisure-focused long-haul flights
D) Concentrating on destinations with high onward connectivity

4. What is Delta Airlines’ primary objective in terms of customer service?

A) Minimizing costs and risk
B) Commanding a revenue premium through brand loyalty
C) Achieving a consistently high on-time rating
D) Expanding its network routes

5. What is the main reason why Denver is a better hub for United Airlines than Salt Lake City?

A) Geographical location for serving north-south passenger flows
B) Larger local market, limitless room for airport expansion, and strategic geographic location
C) Presence of major tourist destinations
D) Partnership with other airlines

Answer Key:

1. C
2. B
3. C
4. C
5. B

Grammar Focus

Grammar Focus: Using the Present Perfect Continuous Tense to Describe Ongoing Situations

The present perfect continuous tense is used to describe actions that started in the past and continue up to the present moment. In the context of the US airlines industry, this tense can be used to talk about the ongoing competitive strategies and network designs of airlines. For example, “United Airlines has been focusing on leisure-focused long-haul flights” or “Delta Airlines has been serving nine Mexican airports.” This tense is formed using the present perfect form of “to be” (has/have been) + the -ing form of the verb. It is often used with time expressions such as “since,” “for,” and “recently” to provide more information about the duration of the action.

Grammar Quiz:

1. By the time Delta Airlines announced its new route, United Airlines ____________________ its services to include more destinations in the Caribbean.

A) has expanded
B) is expanding
C) has been expanding
D) expands

2. American Airlines ____________________ its domestic network for years, making it a strong competitor in the US market.

A) has been prioritizing
B) prioritizes
C) is prioritizing
D) prioritize

3. Since its inception, Delta Airlines ____________________ a reputation for being a premium airline with high-quality services.

A) has built
B) is building
C) has been building
D) builds

4. The US airlines industry ____________________ by a complex web of competitive strategies and network designs for decades.

A) has been characterized
B) is characterized
C) characterizes
D) has characterized

5. By next year, United Airlines ____________________ its fleet to include more fuel-efficient planes, reducing its carbon footprint.

A) will have expanded
B) is expanding
C) has been expanding
D) expands

Answer Key:

1. C) has been expanding

2. A) has been prioritizing

3. C) has been building

4. A) has been characterized

5. A) will have expanded